The blog for books and movies

Twilight vs Harry Potter

Which books are better? Are you Team Edward or Team Jacob? Do you wish you could go to a school like Harry’s? Let the argument begin!

Comments on: "Twilight vs Harry Potter" (580)

  1. Grace said:

    Harry Potter and Twilight are truly rivals, there is no question to be said. They are both novels that appeal to both fantasy and action loving readers, so there is quite a lot to be said.

    Let’s begin with J.K Rowling’s Harry Potter. Harry Potter is really predictable and quite self obsessed, he is supposed to be a really brave character and a good ‘role model’ but if you rip off all those layers of glamour you get back to that boy under the stairs. Harry should’ve been in Slytherin and Hermione in Ravenclaw, that was truly a mistake on the sorting hats behalf. Also, it should’ve been Harry and Hermione instead of Ron. But on the brighter side, Harry Potter really does have some really good morals to the story and I do really love the Weasly twins.

    Twilight is all based around the romance between Isabella (Bella) Swan and vampire Edward Cullen. But, there is also the guarantee of some major plot twists throughout the whole story. Some of the things that let this novel down are Edwards quite over the top anger problems and the fact that Bella is quite useless when influenced by Edward. On the other hand, it really is a story that makes you want to keep reading, it really draws you in.

    So, for me it’s got to be Harry Potter- but only just!

    Like

  2. Sybilla said:

    Twilight all the way. I find twilight more interesting it doesn’t just repeat it self. I find Harry Potter does a bit.

    Like

  3. morrissey said:

    As Dumbledore says: “It is the choices harry that show us who we truly are far more than our abilities” and that pretty much sums up why harry potter is better

    Like

  4. having grown up with Harry potter I love these books to pieces!
    the stories just hooked me in straight away and i never put the books down in fact i am still in love with them! these books are so very special to me they are like my best friend i never really had
    always (;

    Like

  5. morrissey said:

    Harry Potter by far it has more action and magic and it has auesome characters such as hermione granger and harry potter inspires lots of people like hermione shows that brains arnt everything harry shows that justice pays off and ron shows that friendship is one of the most important things in your life

    Liked by 1 person

  6. twilight is just full of people that can not act and all they care about is kissing.
    all the way
    HARRY POTTERRRRRRRRRR!!!!

    Like

  7. Obviously HARRY POTTOR!!!! These are the most heartfelt, intense, creative, original, funny and fantastically AWESOME!

    Like

  8. Payton said:

    I think that Harry Potter has the best storyline and is overall an amazing series of books and movies.

    Like

  9. Layla said:

    i love harry potter once dad said that i could not read harry potter the half blood prince and don’t judge i cried and got really upset. Any way harry potter is definitely the best because it is got i lot of adventure in it and a bit of romance to get it going i think everyone has to read harry potter if they don’t the are not cool!!!!!!!!

    Like

    • Layla said:

      ALSO HARRY POTTER IS definitely THE BEST BOOK EVER TWILIGHT IS SO BORING!!!!!!!ASK ANY ONE WOULD THEY PREFERE TO READ Team Edward or Team Jacob OR HOGWARTS!! AWESOMENESS GO HARRY POTTER 🙂 🙂

      Like

  10. I actually love Harry Potter so much it is the best book in the whole world and I love it so, so much. I have never seen Twilight and i don’t really want to because it seems rather boring. Harry Potter is full of excitement and magic. Twilight is just about vampires and I’m not really sure what else but it seems dark and boring. The first 3 years of Harry’s Hogwarts experience are my favourites because it is when he just found out that he is a wizard and he finally get’s to leave his horrible aunt and uncles house. All my friends know how much i love harry potter and I’m not ashamed because it’s honestly the best book I have ever read and I love JK Rowling so so much.

    Like

  11. Ashleigh said:

    TWILIGHT IS AN AMAZING BOOK SERIES THE BEST BOOK SERIES YOU WILL EVER READ!! THE RELATIONSHIPS AND THRILL OF EDWARD BEING ATTRACTED TO BELLA AND NOT BEING ABLE TO READ HER MIND IT MUST OF DRIVEN HIM CRAZY! I fell in love with this book and its characters and I will always remember the first time I read twilight!

    Like

  12. Harry Potter 100%. harry, ron and Hermione vs vampires? well wizards have defeated vampires before sooo… they’re both great but I’m a potter head through and through

    Like

  13. Elizabeth said:

    If you prefer twightlight instead of harry potter there is something is wrong. maybe you did not read the book. Harry potter is amazing

    Like

  14. Ainsley said:

    Harry Potter by far. Twilight is pretty boring Vampires really? I know that Harry Potter isn’t real but what kid doesn’t want to go to Hogwarts????!!!!!

    Like

  15. Harry Potter 100%. I don’t have anything against Twilight and actually had a good time reading it but Harry Potter had a much better storyline and a much more worthy cause. I mean in Harry Potter they fight for a better future, world and because they want there loved ones to be safe. In twilight, for the first three books Bella fights to become a vampire and to decide which of her ‘two lover/friends’ she wants to be with more. Individually Twilight was a great book but in comparison to Harry Potter it doesn’t even come close.

    Like

  16. Rhani said:

    The two books have something in common the fantasy… you don’t see everyday a wizard walk down the street or a vampire sparkling in the sun. If I had to choose I’d always go with one specific book or movie TWILIGHT!!!!!!!!!! I’m a twilight fan through and through. Harry Potter is ok but at the end of the day vampires are still awake not sleeping like a human getting rest for the next day. Good luck Harry Potter but I hope twilight wins.
    And remember keep calm and love reading

    Like

  17. Salina said:

    Tough one, i really don’t know who to choose?
    i have seen two twilight films and all the harry potter movies, so if i had to choose between Twilight or Harry potter… I would have to go for Harry potter!
    There are more people you come across in the harry potter books and movies that you will love and hate. Not a bad choice to choose between these to amazing movies but if your loking for some magic, i’d say that your looking at Harry Potter… No offence Twilight fans

    Like

  18. Sienna said:

    I would definently choose harry potter in a heart beat because it is so much more captivating and entertaining to read and watch. I’ve read all of the books and I absolutely loved them all and there all fun and enjoyable to read. I’ve also watched all of the movies and there just as good to watch all over harry potter it a great series on its own and now it even has its own theme park now!!! the harry potter series is great for ages 12 and above.
    Well its 100% better than twilight series and thats all that needs to be said!!!

    Like

  19. hermione, harry and ron fort for the wizarding world, to stop evil and risked themselfs for others, Bella Swan just sits there letting her sparkling boyfriend do all the work, I would rather be in the Arena than be Bella Swan

    Like

  20. harry potter is better, a story about three students, fighting for their lives beats a story about a sparkling vampire, anyday.

    Like

  21. sophie said:

    Before I read twilight I would of said that there couldn’t possibly be a better series than harry potter, but there is!
    In harry potter its good but in some bits it gets kind of boring because it goes on and on and keeps repeating the same story line – but twilight theres no boring bits and you just can’t put the book down. Its got more romance which I love and a way better story line.

    Like

  22. Harry Potter by far, Twilight doesn’t interest me at all

    Like

  23. Harry Potter is so much better in my opinion by far! Twilight isn’t that engaging to me, if I was to choose to be a wizard or a vampire it’s obvious what I would pick.

    Like

  24. Hannah Shepherd said:

    Harry Potter

    Like

  25. Lydia said:

    I much prefere HARRY POTTER because it drags on a while and it keeps you hanging and eating for the next book to arrive in your hands, I have read the twilight series and the Harry Potter series, and I LOVE the HARRY POTTER series.

    Like

  26. I think harry potter is better because it has so much action and spells. You never know whats going to happen next so its so exciting. Harry potter gets you wondering whats going to happen next.

    Like

  27. harry potter bets alllllll!! ❤

    Like

  28. Harry Potter.
    The mysteries and the storey lines set the movie perfectly.
    There just amazing

    Like